Moments & Supernovas: Exploring the breakup of England’s 2005 bowling attack

England’s 2005 Ashes triumph was not supposed to be the team’s apogee, but the launchpad for a bold and glorious new era of global domination. In defeating Australia, England had travelled the long road from catastrophe to prosperity, a journey that had encompassed 16 long years of humiliation and disappointment. After that, what could possibly stand in their way?

A Perfect Moment

The beating heart of England’s victory was the team’s five-man bowling attack, an unlikely cast of characters who combined to fell the Australians with a potent cocktail of wit, aggression and reverse swing.

With an average age of just under 28, Andrew Flintoff, Ashley Giles, Steve Harmison, Matthew Hoggard and Simon Jones were — with the possible exception of Giles (who was 32 at the time) — widely expected to spearhead England’s attack for years to come. Fate, however, had made alternative arrangements.

Looking back from a distance of a dozen years, 2005 represents the only time circumstance allowed those five bowlers to form a forceful and cohesive unit. As each member of the quintet explored the pinnacle of their physical and psychological capacities, there was no way of knowing the divestiture that was to come. It was a perfect, luminous moment that was ultimately to be extinguished in the shadow of its own glory.

Jones & Giles: Journey’s End

For Simon Jones, England’s master of reverse swing and conjuror of the magnificent delivery that removed Michael Clarke’s off stump at Old Trafford, the summer of 2005 would be his last in an England shirt. Blighted by knee and ankle injuries, Jones’ body struggled to tolerate the pneumatic violence of his bowling action and forcibly curtailed the Welshman’s highly promising career.

Like Jones, Ashley Giles didn’t last much longer at international level. Having responded emphatically to criticism with a series of impressive all-round displays against Australia, the versatile left-arm spinner struggled to recreate his best form after the Ashes. Three wickets in two games on the tour of Pakistan that winter represented a disappointing return and, following an injury that forced him to miss the summer of 2006, the Warwickshire spinner’s place was snatched away by Monty Panesar.

Giles returned to the side for the opening two Tests of the 2006/07 tour Down Under, but his three wickets came at 87.3 runs apiece before he flew home to be with his ill wife. It was a subdued end to a Test career that had seen the King of Spain squeeze every last drop of talent from his body as he fought to hold on to his position as his country’s premier slow bowler.

Freddie: Rise & Fall

If Giles was the member of England’s attack who had to work the hardest to reach his full potential, Andrew Flintoff was at the other end of the spectrum. An instinctive and bullish player of mercurial genius, Flintoff made the summer of 2005 his own. From box-office batting to spells of intense hostility with ball in hand, there were times during the series when ‘Freddie’ stole the momentum of entire matches through sheer force of will.

The 2005 Ashes established Flintoff as arguably the most celebrated sportsman in England. Bestowed with countless accolades and revelling in his image as the People’s Champion, Flintoff became an intersection for the worlds of cricket and celebrity. Awarded the Test captaincy in 2006 following an injury to Michael Vaughan, Flintoff initially performed well under the burden of added responsibility but it didn’t take long for cracks to appear.

Returning from injury to lead England on the 2006/07 Ashes tour, Flintoff ultimately carried the can for his side’s surrender in their humiliating 5–0 whitewash. Struggling for form and criticised for disjointed captaincy, Flintoff had been reduced from Titan to mere mortal in the space of a year. The seasons that followed brought more injuries, indiscreet extra-curricular drinking and an infamous pedalo incident before Flintoff’s international career was brought to an end in 2009.

In 2005 it appeared as though Flintoff, a force of nature with no limit to his audacity, was on course to bestride the cricketing world. Instead, Freddie’s career stalled amid a series of setbacks, as many of them self-inflicted as purely unfortunate. That single Ashes summer now rests as a dazzling jewel in what is a slightly tarnished crown.

Hoggy & Harmy: The Long Goodbye

A pair of delightfully eccentric characters, Matthew Hoggard and Steve Harmison led England’s attack with the new ball throughout the 2005 Ashes as their combination of intelligent swing (Hoggard) and raw pace (Harmison) proved a potent one. However, just as they shared Australian wickets that summer, so they both gradually faded from the international scene in the years that followed.

A survivor from the previous series Down Under, Hoggard had done a lot of growing up between 2002/03 and 2005. The Australian top-order had feasted on his gentle swing in 2002 as the Yorkshireman took just six wickets in three Tests at an average of 62.5. Two-and-a-half years later, more experienced and assisted by English conditions, ‘Hoggy’ caused Australia serious problems with the new ball as he claimed 16 wickets at 29.56.

Hoggard struggled for consistency after 2005 but still showed occasional flashes of his undoubted ability. Returning to Australia in 2006, Hoggard took 7–109 in the first innings at Adelaide before England robbed themselves of a draw by subsiding at the hands of Shane Warne. Hoggard’s 13 scalps made him England’s top wicket-taker on that disastrous tour, the last series in which he was indisputably one of his country’s frontline bowlers. The lumbering, shy bowler played just five more Tests over the next 18 months before retiring to the quiet life he so desired.

Highly erratic but capable of brilliance, Harmison came into the Ashes on the back of an outstanding run of form that had seen him decimate New Zealand and West Indies (twice) in the space of just six months in 2004. Capable of producing near-unplayable spells of genuinely fast bowling, Harmison was in the prime of his career in 2005 and set about proving it with a lethal spell on the first morning at Lord’s that bruised Justin Langer and scarred the face of Ricky Ponting. His 17 wickets in the series included 10 top-order batsmen and often came at crucial stages, his masterful slower ball to Michael Clarke at Edgbaston being the prime example.

Just as he set the tone in 2005, Harmison would do the same in more unfortunate circumstances in 2006. In one of several bouts of anxious bowling that marked his career, Harmison delivered the first ball of the series into the hands of Andrew Flintoff at second slip. That moment marked the beginning of the end for the Geordie fast bowler. Harmison summoned one last prolific series (16 wickets at 34.25 against West Indies in 2007) before injuries and inconsistency eventually saw him lose favour with the selectors.


Of the combined 281 Tests played by the members of England’s 2005 bowling quintet, just 81 (28.8%) came after the Ashes victory. Reflecting on that halcyon summer, it’s hard to escape the sense that reclaiming the Ashes was such a Herculean task that it left England victorious but physically and emotionally diminished. Having vanquished the old enemy in such dramatic circumstances, what worlds were there left to conquer?

The summer of 2005 could have been a starting point for English domination of Test cricket, but negotiating the whims of reality is rarely that straightforward. Instead, the series stands as a monument to the reversal of history, the fulfilment of an ambition, and the apex of England’s curve under Michael Vaughan’s leadership. Like a dying star, England’s victory was the last, most dazzling burst of light from a team that dissipated in the brilliance of a beautiful supernova.

Image: Pixabay


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: